Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Next 30, Your Terms's avatar

As someone who grew up in India, I found it fascinating. We often assume exceptional craftsmanship is enough, but this piece is a reminder that craftsmanship builds the product, while storytelling builds the brand.

And perhaps the biggest lesson is this: the world doesn’t always reward the best work. It rewards the work people have been taught to value.

That’s a lesson that extends far beyond jewelry.

p.s. always love reading your pieces

Nikita's avatar

v much resonates with how south indian families like mine treat gold. the designs don't matter except maybe for the bride, lol (the younger ones call a piece ugly because it is an old, chunky, not aesthetic design but is a valued piece because of the amount of gold). on top of that, my now retired father trusts ONLY tanishq to be transparent and honest about the amount of gold, because tatas. tanishq also did a bunch of things a few years ago where families could take their old family gold jewellery back (even the non-tanishq, locally made, likely not pure gold jewellery) to tanishq and get a good amount of store credit or something similar.

but no one will say they're wearing a tanishq, they'll aay they're buying an x gram gold bracelet for example, or describe the stones. brands and storytelling almost feel like a first world problem. these are not families that would spend tons of money on a designer saree or on a "story". otoh, when the nirav modi story had broken out, while I was hearing about him for the first time, I remember reading a blog by some delhi kid about how (south?) delhi elites used to name drop wearing nirav modi jewels as a status symbol and how they're going to change tunes now. that was my first intro to the other kind of jewellery business in india, where brands add to the value of the piece. I never went deeper into it because at the time I couldn't care less about jewellery but the last couple of years I am being drawn more and more into how luxury brands have built a myth around themselves even as they bank on the work and myths of other parts of the world (I'm thinking prada's kolhapuri chappals too here), not just from a "haw, western imperialists!" take but also from a "why are they able to market it and why can't we" side so this was a good read for me!

japan is an exception that's broken into the luxury segment that was dominated by europe, but like you said, they've played by western rules. atp feels like you're considered luxury if the west considers you luxury? watches also seem similar in this regard (although ofc in watches, unlike jewellery and textiles, we are significantly younger in the business and we don't have the legacy of craftsmanship that we do in jewellery and textiles.)

2 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?